• Login
  • Register
Speedcafe.com
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • PODCASTS
  • PHOTOS
  • CALENDAR
  • RESULTS & STANDINGS
  • NETWORK
No Result
View All Result
  • Supercars
  • F1
  • NASCAR
  • INDYCAR
  • SRO GT
  • KARTING
  • RALLY
  • BIKES
  • Win Tundra & Caravan
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • PODCASTS
  • PHOTOS
  • CALENDAR
  • RESULTS & STANDINGS
  • NETWORK
No Result
View All Result
  • Feed
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Photos
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
Speedcafe.com
  • Supercars
  • F1
  • NASCAR
  • IndyCar
  • SRO GT
  • Karting
  • Rally
  • Bikes
  • Win Tundra & Caravan
  • FastDeli Club
Home F1

Felipe Massa expected to lose legal fight against F1 and FIA

Felipe Massa is expected to lose his $125 million legal challenge against the FIA and Formula 1 over the outcome of the 2008 world championship.

Mat Coch
Mat Coch
1 Apr 2024
Mat Coch
//
1 Apr 2024
// F1
A A
0
Felipe Massa expected to lose legal fight against F1 and FIA
Felipe Massa is expected to lose his legal challenge of F1 and the FIA. Image GEPA / xpb.cc

Felipe Massa is expected to lose his legal challenge of F1 and the FIA. Image GEPA / xpb.cc

Felipe Massa is expected to lose his legal challenge of F1 and the FIA. Image GEPA / xpb.cc

Massa lost the title that year in a dramatic finale to Lewis Hamilton, who famously overtook Timo Glock on the run out of the final corner of the final lap of the final race.

It created a surreal sequence of events where Massa, who won the race, looked to have claimed the title, only for Hamilton to scrape through to steal it away in the seconds that followed.

However, the Brazilian driver’s grievance does not focus on that event and instead relates to that year’s Singapore Grand Prix, where Renault influenced the outcome.

In Marina Bay, Nelson Piquet was instructed to crash his car at a specific location in order to better the chances of team-mate Fernando Alonso.

As instructed, Piquet crashed while Alonso benefitted from the resulting Safety Car to win the race.

Hamilton finished third in the race, while Massa could do no better than 13th after a pit stop error saw him pull away with the fuel hose still attached to his Ferrari.

It only came to light well after the fact that the race had, effectively, been rigged.

Piquet made the revelation once he was sacked from the team during the 2009 season, which prompted an investigation into the matter.

That saw Renault team boss Flavio Briatore and technical director Pat Symonds handed lifetime bans from the sport – later overturned by a French court.

More recently, F1’s former commercial boss Bernie Ecclestone admitted he knew of the allegations before the conclusion of the 2008 season.

And so, more than 15 years after Hamilton was crowned world champion in Brazil, Massa has launched legal action.

The 42-year-old is seeking £64 million in damages, his estimate for the income lost by not winning the 2008 title.

His argument centres on the fact the FIA could have intervened before the prize-giving ceremony that year but did not.

As a result, the race result stood, and Hamilton was crowned – a fact that now cannot be challenged.

Since he cannot be crowned world champion, Massa is instead seeking damages.

However, the logic appears based on the false premise that the FIA could have done something about the outcome of the Singapore Grand Prix.

Massa’s case hangs on the fact that the FIA could have acted before the FIA prize-giving ceremony and, had it done, the outcome of the world championship may have been different.

That belief, and the legal challenge it has launched, is born from the notion that the result of the Singapore Grand Prix could be annulled.

Under the regulations, there is no facility for race results to be annulled, a point that was proven in court earlier this year.

A recent outcome from the FIA International Court of Appeal has relevance to Massa’s plight as it ruled on the ability of officials to annul race results.

That particular document relates to a GT race held in Austria last year, where a mismanaged Safety Car impacted the outcome of a race.

At the time, Team Motopark was disadvantaged under the Safety Car with a series of protests and appeals eventually landing the matter in front of the International Court of Appeal.

During those appeals, the Spanish motorsport authority (which governs the International GT Open competition) annulled the race classification, a point the ICA noted it did not have the authority to do.

A 24-page document published by the FIA on the outcome of that hearing noted that “neither the Stewards nor the NCA had the power to cancel the Race.”

It is important to note that while the neither Stewards nor the local governing body had the power to annul the race, the International Court of Appeal does under the FIA’s Judicial and Disciplinary Rules.

“The ICA has all the decision-making powers of the authority that took the contested decision,” declares Article 10.11.1 of the JDRs states.

It is followed by 10.11.2, which adds: “In addition, the ICA may admit or dismiss the appeal, in whole or in part, and may decide to confirm, waive or mitigate the penalty inflicted. It may also increase such a penalty, unless the appeal has only been lodged by the party being subject of the appealed decision. Finally, it may annul or amend the results of a competition, but it is not empowered to order any competition to be re-run.”

However, the process to bring the matter to the ISC can only the commenced by a competitor, a point laid out in Article 13.1.1 of the ISC: “The right to protest lies only with a Competitor.”

As no competitor lodged a protest, the Singapore result could never have escalated to the International Court of Appeal and hence could never have been annulled.

Of course, there are moral questions that the scenario doesn’t answer, such as whether Ecclestone or any other individuals who knew of the collusion should have informed a competitor.

Whether that would have led to anything is unlikely as the ICA, in its decision earlier this year, noted the underlying premise of “sporting fairness” in the International Sporting Code.

In that instance, the underlying fundamental premise prevented the International Court of Appeal from amending the classification, as it would have impacted more teams and drivers than it otherwise did.

Applying that to the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix, annulling the result would have impacted all teams – more than just Massa or any single competitor.

But there’s also another fundamental point that the legal challenge ignores, and that is the simple fact the 2008 Formula 1 season was contested over 18 races.

None of those events were more meaningful or worth more than any other, making Massa’s failure to score points in Singapore no different than his engine failures in Hungary and Australia, or his own performances in Silverstone and Malaysia.

His championship loss was not down to a specific event but the culmination of all 18 events.

To cite Singapore as the reason he was not champion is to take a distorted and simplistic view on the matter.

If he’s looking to take legal action against the FIA and F1, he should by rights lodge a similar complaint against Ferrari for its failure to provide him with a suitable engine at the Hungarian and Australian Grands Prix.

Given that, and the inability of the sport’s regulators to have made any change to the results anyway, Massa faces an uphill struggle to win his legal battle.

Tags: f1ferrarifiahamiltonmassa

Join the Network

Ultimate Diesel Tuning

Automotive & Performance

Ultimate Diesel Tuning (UDT) is an Australian aftermarket turbo-diesel mechanical performance upgrade & custom dyno tuning company. Our performance centres have THREE fantastic locations with in-house dynos at both: Geebung in Brisbane, Dandenong in Melbourne...

Ultimate Diesel Tuning (UDT) is an Australian aftermarket turbo-diesel mechanical performance upgrade & custom dyno tuning company. Our performance centres have THREE fantastic locations with...

Discussion about this post

Latest from Torquecafe

Porsche delays crucial new model

21 May 2025

Revealed: Most important new model of 2025

21 May 2025

Toyota vows to only make “fun” cars

21 May 2025

Freelander to return… as a Chinese EV brand

21 May 2025

Latest Podcasts

PODCAST: Imola F1 unpacked, Penske Indy 500 scandal & Basil’s blunder

20 May 2025

PODCAST: Supercars CEO race heats up + Bathurst 12 Hour takeover explained

16 May 2025

Related Articles

F1 and Disney have struck a deal. Image: Supplied

Disney and F1 launch ‘powerhouse’ collaboration

F1
1 day ago
F1
0

PODCAST: Imola F1 unpacked, Penske Indy 500 scandal & Basil’s blunder

Podcasts
2 days ago
Podcasts
0

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Platinum Partner

Latest & Trending News

Scott McLaughlin (right) celebrates with Team Penske president Tim Cindric.

Axe swings on Cindric amid Penske cheating allegations

IndyCar
22 May 2025
IndyCar
0
DJR new chassis shakedown at Queensland Raceway - Image: InSyde Media

GALLERY: DJR Shakedown at Queensland Raceway

Photo Galleries
21 May 2025
Photo Galleries
0
Leigh Diffey (left) with Townsend Bell.

Australian motorsport broadcast icon wins Emmy

General
21 May 2025
General
0

Michelin Race Guide: MotoGP Grand Prix of the United Kingdom

Michelin Race Guide
21 May 2025
Michelin Race Guide
0
Andrew Houlihan with his KTM bike.

‘This is personal’: Australian off-road racer set for landmark return

Offroad
21 May 2025
Offroad
0
DJR's new Mustang at Queensland Raceway. Image: InSyde Media

Supercars undertaking further Ford engine testing

Supercars
21 May 2025
Supercars
0
Pirtek Poll

POLL: Is Warburton the leader Supercars needs?

Vote View Results Past polls
Pirtek Poll
View past polls
2025 Supercars Championship WINS POLES PTS
1
Broc Feeney
Red Bull Ampol Racing
88 3 5 894
2
Will Brown
Red Bull Ampol Racing
1 1 1 861
3
Matthew Payne
Penrite Racing
19 3 1 819
4
Cam Waters
Monster Castrol Racing
6 3 3 803
5
Chaz Mostert
Mobil1 Optus Racing
25 1 0 644
2025 Formula 1 Championship WINS POLES PTS
1
Oscar Piastri (AUS)
McLaren
81 4 3 146
2
Lando Norris (GBR)
McLaren
4 1 1 133
3
Max Verstappen (NED)
Red Bull
1 2 3 124
4
George Russell (GBR)
Mercedes
63 0 0 99
5
Charles Leclerc (MON)
Ferrari
16 0 0 61
[instagram-feed feed=2]
Support the partners that support Speedcafe
Truck Assist R & J Batteries Pirtek Mobil Super Supercheap Auto Michelin Meguiars coates XPEL FORD ACDelco parcelprotect become a partner
AASA PPQ Authentic Collectables sportsnetholidays nuevasolutions
Speedcafe.com has been established to provide a daily motorsport news service to the industry and fans in Australia and internationally.
Follow Us

Categories

SUPERCARS

F1

NASCAR

INDYCAR

GT

MOTOGP

PHOTOS

TV

PODS

Platinum Partners

TRUCK ASSIST
R&J BATTERIES
PIRTEK
MOBIL1
SUPERCHEAP AUTO

PARCEL PROTECT

MICHELIN
MEGUIARS

COATES
FORD

XPEL

ACDELCO

Newsletter

Subscribe to our daily newsletter, the best way to get your news first, fast and free!

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Your daily racing fix - Newsletter

Subscribe to our daily and breaking newsletter for all the latest news delivered direct to your box

SUBSCRIBE
Follow Us

Categories

SUPERCARS

F1

NASCAR

INDYCAR

GT

MOTOGP

PHOTOS

TV

PODS

Platinum Partners

TRUCK ASSIST
R&J BATTERIES
PIRTEK
MOBIL1
SUPERCHEAP AUTO

PARCEL PROTECT

MICHELIN
MEGUIARS

COATES
FORD

XPEL

ACDELCO

Copyright © 2025 Speedcafe.com. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Our Team    /  Advertise with us  /  Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Event guides
  • Podcasts
  • SHOP
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Speedcafe Network
  • FastDeli Club

Copyright © 2023 Speedcafe.com This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Event guides
  • Podcasts
  • SHOP
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Speedcafe Network
  • FastDeli Club

Copyright © 2023 Speedcafe.com This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.