• Login
  • Register
Speedcafe.com
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • PODCASTS
  • PHOTOS
  • CALENDAR
  • RESULTS & STANDINGS
  • NETWORK
No Result
View All Result
  • Supercars
  • F1
  • NASCAR
  • INDYCAR
  • SRO GT
  • KARTING
  • RALLY
  • BIKES
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • PODCASTS
  • PHOTOS
  • CALENDAR
  • RESULTS & STANDINGS
  • NETWORK
No Result
View All Result
  • Feed
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Photos
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
Speedcafe.com
  • Supercars
  • F1
  • NASCAR
  • IndyCar
  • SRO GT
  • Karting
  • Rally
  • Bikes
  • FastDeli Club
Home F1

ANALYSIS: The red flag ruined Monaco

A red flag on the opening lap destroyed any hope of the Monaco Grand Prix being anything but a procession.

Mat Coch
Mat Coch
28 May 2024
Mat Coch
//
28 May 2024
// F1
A A
0
ANALYSIS: The red flag ruined Monaco
Charles Leclerc (MON) Ferrari SF-24. 26.05.2024. Formula 1 World Championship, Rd 8, Monaco Grand Prix, Monte Carlo, Monaco, Race Day. - www.xpbimages.com, EMail: [email protected] © Copyright: Coates / XPB Images

A red flag on the opening lap destroyed any hope of the Monaco Grand Prix being anything but a procession. Image: Coates / XPB Images

A red flag on the opening lap destroyed any hope of the Monaco Grand Prix being anything but a procession. Image: Coates / XPB Images

The Monaco Grand Prix has, for many decades, been an event that centres around qualifying on Saturday afternoon.

Overtaking is near impossible, and as a result, grid position is more critical there than anywhere else.

Save the odd weather-affected race, Monaco is a procession and deserves to have its place on the calendar questioned – though that’s a whole different topic.

The one hope of something other than that on Sunday was the prospect of race strategy, especially with two Ferraris and two McLarens at the front.

In normal circumstances, teams could have used strategy to attempt to force a way through, with gaps in the pack opening up for the leaders to drop into as they dived into the lane.

However, there was no need for anyone to pit because under the current red flag rules, teams can change tyres, and have it count as a compulsory stop.

That simple fact created an especially dull Monaco Grand Prix without even the intrigue pit stops might have afforded (remember how important they were in 2016…?).

Under red flag rules, teams can not only change tyres but also affect repairs. Oscar Piastri was given a new sidepod cover, and mechanics attempted to repair his damaged floor as best they could following contact from Carlos Sainz.

It also meant Sainz could have his punctured tyre replaced and regain third for the restart, despite having ground to a halt at Casino Square and fallen to last.

There is no question a red flag was essential. A photographer was hurt and three cars littered the circuit with debris. A red flag was the only option and is unquestioned.

Everything that happened in pit lane after the stoppage, however, should be questioned. More than that, it should be addressed as a priority because the watching world was robbed of a motor race.

Even the drivers were critical of the regulations as they stand, some with greater vested interests than others.

“Today we’ll definitely ask questions of ‘okay, can we rewrite the rule?’,” quizzed Daniel Ricciardo.

“Obviously if there’s a red flag 10 laps to go, well then there shouldn’t be a compulsory pit stop, but on Lap 1 when the whole race really restarts?

“It was 100 percent the right decision and I’m glad everyone’s okay, but from what then transpired and what is already a boring race, it really cemented the boredom and we really know that everyone was going to try and go to the end.”

Lando Norris was also critical of the rules, branding them unfair.

He’d started fourth and climbed to third after Sainz pulled off at Casino Square, only to hand that place back to the Spaniard under the red flag when the field was reset.

“I think that ruined any other opportunities that might have come my way with strategy and tyre saving and stuff like that,” he said.

“Carlos got quite lucky there was a red flag because he was out, or last, and that was his own fault.

“For him to get back was obviously annoying because it put me back down to fourth.

“But otherwise, yeah, just nothing you could do because there was no pistops, nothing, it was just driving slowly until the end.

“I don’t think it’s the most fair thing, but I’m sure there’s been moments in the past when maybe I’ve been fortunate from it,” he added.

“When you think of it in just the blunt way, it is frustrating and unfair.”

The ability to make changes under red flags is primarily a safety issue.

A damaged or dangerous car cannot be allowed to continue in the race, so if there’s an opportunity to make running repairs, naturally, that makes sense.

And of course, if there’s an opportunity to improve the car mid-race for free, they’d be daft not to take it.

But in any other context, those repairs would come at a price; you’d lose time and, most probably, track position. Why should it be free just because there’s a red flag?

A simple solution would be that, if you want to complete any work on the car, you get sent to the back of the pack. And tyre changes don’t count as a compulsory stop.

Teams then have a choice: repair the car and take the pain, or leave it as is and hope it can survive (provided it’s safe, repairs to an unsafe car should still be sent to the back)?

It’s a simple solution that would reintroduce a degree of jeopardy in races like Monaco. Sure, some would lose and some would win, but it would be more akin to the jeopardy of a Safety Car with the potential to spice up a race, rather than essentially ending it.

Under that premise, Ferrari would have to have changed Sainz’s tyre in Monaco, dropping him to the back and promoting Norris. But what would McLaren have done? Piastri’s car wasn’t dangerous, but would it have lasted?so would they carry on?

And such a move means the pit stop cycle would have still been ahead of us introducing a degree of natural variation and jeopardy.

Instead, we got Charles Leclerc commanding the race, managing his speed so he couldn’t be strategically challenged.

It was a popular win, and an emotional one too, and nobody would deny him that – but it’s how we got to that point that could so easily be tweaked for the betterment of the spectacle without trivialising the action with gimmicks.

Tags: f1ferrarifiamonaconorricciardosainz
speedcafe-network-small

Join the Network

Michelin

Michelin’s tyres reinvent tomorrow’s mobility. Founded in 1889, Michelin has been based on innovation and is the official tyre of Porsche racing globally and MotoGP, along with various other pursuits worldwide. It is the naming...

Michelin’s tyres reinvent tomorrow’s mobility. Founded in 1889, Michelin has been based on innovation and is the official tyre of Porsche racing globally and MotoGP,...

Discussion about this post

Latest from Torquecafe

Environmental agency may kill your car’s most annoying feature

15 May 2025

Porsche’s big problem

15 May 2025

Italian brand returns with Ford-powered supercar

15 May 2025

Chinese EV maker annoys owners twice in a week

15 May 2025

Latest Podcasts

PODCAST: Tasmania Supercars, BJR’s Toyota coup & DJR’s sanding slip-up

14 May 2025

PODCAST: Supercars parity changes explained + Doohan exit verdict

09 May 2025

Related Articles

Oscar Piastri looks at the Lorenzo Bandini Trophy.

Piastri joins legendary list of prestigious F1 award winners

F1
2 hours ago
F1
0
FIA president Mohammed Bin Sulayem during the 2024 Formula 1 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix.

FIA backs down on controversial swearing sanctions

F1
6 hours ago
F1
0

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Platinum Partner

Latest & Trending News

Another Mustang is set to join the GT4 field. Image: Supplied

Supercars rookie and TCM champ join GT4

SRO GT
15 May 2025
SRO GT
0
Oscar Piastri looks at the Lorenzo Bandini Trophy.

Piastri joins legendary list of prestigious F1 award winners

F1
15 May 2025
F1
0

Proposed Perth street circuit layout revealed

Supercars
15 May 2025
Supercars
0
Chaz Mostert's Mustang at Symmons Plains. Image: InSyde Media

Mostert explains Symmons Plains struggle

Supercars
15 May 2025
Supercars
0
Josef Newgarden's view of Indianapolis Motor Speedway.

VIDEO: Indianapolis Motor Speedway from the driver’s eye

Favourite Flick
15 May 2025
Favourite Flick
0
Chase Briscoe's #19 Bass Pro Shops Toyota Camry he'll race in the 2025 Coca-Cola 600.

Aussie designer adds NASCAR team to illustrious portfolio

NASCAR
15 May 2025
NASCAR
0
Pirtek Poll

POLL: Will Toyota win a Supercars race in 2026?

Vote View Results Past polls
Pirtek Poll
View past polls
2025 Supercars Championship WINS POLES PTS
1
Broc Feeney
Red Bull Ampol Racing
88 3 5 894
2
Will Brown
Red Bull Ampol Racing
1 1 1 861
3
Matthew Payne
Penrite Racing
19 3 1 819
4
Cam Waters
Monster Castrol Racing
6 3 3 803
5
Chaz Mostert
Mobil1 Optus Racing
25 1 0 644
2025 Formula 1 Championship WINS POLES PTS
1
Oscar Piastri (AUS)
McLaren
81 4 2 131
2
Lando Norris (GBR)
McLaren
4 1 1 115
3
Max Verstappen (NED)
Red Bull
1 1 3 99
4
George Russell (GBR)
Mercedes
63 0 0 93
5
Charles Leclerc (MON)
Ferrari
16 0 0 53
[instagram-feed feed=2]
Support the partners that support Speedcafe
Truck Assist R & J Batteries Pirtek Mobil Super Supercheap Auto Michelin Meguiars coates XPEL FORD ACDelco parcelprotect become a partner
AASA PPQ Authentic Collectables bathurst sportsnetholidays nuevasolutions
Speedcafe.com has been established to provide a daily motorsport news service to the industry and fans in Australia and internationally.
Follow Us

Categories

SUPERCARS

F1

NASCAR

INDYCAR

GT

MOTOGP

PHOTOS

TV

PODS

Platinum Partners

TRUCK ASSIST
R&J BATTERIES
PIRTEK
MOBIL1
SUPERCHEAP AUTO

PARCEL PROTECT

MICHELIN
MEGUIARS

COATES
FORD

XPEL

ACDELCO

Newsletter

Subscribe to our daily newsletter, the best way to get your news first, fast and free!

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Your daily racing fix - Newsletter

Subscribe to our daily and breaking newsletter for all the latest news delivered direct to your box

SUBSCRIBE
Follow Us

Categories

SUPERCARS

F1

NASCAR

INDYCAR

GT

MOTOGP

PHOTOS

TV

PODS

Platinum Partners

TRUCK ASSIST
R&J BATTERIES
PIRTEK
MOBIL1
SUPERCHEAP AUTO

PARCEL PROTECT

MICHELIN
MEGUIARS

COATES
FORD

XPEL

ACDELCO

Copyright © 2025 Speedcafe.com. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Our Team    /  Advertise with us  /  Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Event guides
  • Podcasts
  • SHOP
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Speedcafe Network
  • FastDeli Club

Copyright © 2023 Speedcafe.com This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Event guides
  • Podcasts
  • SHOP
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Speedcafe Network
  • FastDeli Club

Copyright © 2023 Speedcafe.com This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.