• Login
  • Register
Speedcafe.com
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • PODS
  • PHOTOS
  • RESULTS
  • NETWORK 100
No Result
View All Result
  • SUPERCARS
  • F1
  • MOTOGP
  • NASCAR
  • INDYCAR
  • GT & ENDURANCE
  • KARTING
  • RALLY
  • CHRISTMAS GIVEAWAY
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • PODS
  • PHOTOS
  • RESULTS
  • NETWORK 100
No Result
View All Result
  • Feed
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Photos
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
Speedcafe.com
  • Supercars
  • F1
  • NASCAR
  • IndyCar
  • GT & Endurance
  • Karting
  • Bikes
  • Rally
Home F1

FIA reject McLaren Right of Appeal over Norris penalty

McLaren has had its Right of Appeal petition over Lando Norris’ five-second time penalty in the United States Grand Prix rejected by the FIA.

Mat Coch
Mat Coch
26 Oct 2024
Mat Coch
//
26 Oct 2024
// F1
A A
0
FIA reject McLaren Right of Appeal over Norris penalty
McLaren has had its Right of Appeal petition over Lando Norris’ five-second time penalty in the United States Grand Prix rejected by the FIA. Image: Bearne / XPB Images

McLaren has had its Right of Appeal petition over Lando Norris’ five-second time penalty in the United States Grand Prix rejected by the FIA. Image: Bearne / XPB Images

McLaren has had its Right of Appeal petition over Lando Norris’ five-second time penalty in the United States Grand Prix rejected by the FIA. Image: Bearne / XPB Images

McLaren exercised its Right of Appeal on Thursday (local time) over the penalty that dropped Norris from third on the road in Circuit of The Americas to fourth behind Max Verstappen.

Norris was penalised for leaving the road and gaining a lasting advantage late in last Sunday’s race.

The McLaren driver ran around the outside of his title rival as they scrapped for third place, arguably pushed there by the Red Bull Racing driver as he defended the apex of Turn 12.

However, Verstappen too ran wide, a point noted by officials at the time, who nonetheless deemed Norris had gained a lasting advantage.

Under the Right of Review process, teams are obliged to present relevant evidence that wasn’t available at the time of the original decision.

The two-part process first meets to establish whether that criteria has been met and, if satisfied, then progresses to a re-evaluation of the incident.

Win a pair of Ryan Wood's race-worn signed gloves - One day only! Enter now.

In this instance, the FIA did not feel McLaren’s submission was not relevant or new.

McLaren entered the initial hearing arguing the original decision made statements that were incorrect, specifically that “Car 4 was overtaking Car 1 on the outside but was not level with Car 1 at the apex.”

According to the outcome of the initial Right of Review hearing, it was claimed that the “statement was in error because McLaren had evidence that Car 4 had already overtaken and was ahead of Car 1 ‘at the braking zone’.

“That this error is significant and relevant and is new and was unavailable to McLaren at the time of the decision.”

It was a view rebuffed by Red Bull Racing whose representative, sporting director Jonathan Wheatley, argued McLaren had in fact not met any criteria for the Right of Appeal.

The heart of McLaren’s argument lie in the fact it believed Norris was in fact the defending car, and not Verstappen, a point which, in theory, would change the way in which the driving guidelines would be applied.

“McLaren appears to submit that the Stewards finding that ‘Car 4 was not level with Car 1 at the apex’ was an error and that Car 4 had overtaken Car 1 before the apex (and therefore that Car 1 was the overtaking car) and that this asserted error is itself, a new element,” the FIA outcome document noted.

“This is unsustainable.

“A petition for review is made in order to correct an error (of fact or law) in a decision. Any new element must demonstrate that error.

“The error that must be shown to exist, cannot itself be the element referred to in Article 14.

“In this case, the concept that the written Decision (document number 69) was the significant and relevant new element, or that an error in the decision was a new element, is not sustainable and is, therefore rejected.

“Accordingly, as there is no relevant new element, the Petition is rejected.”

McLaren subsequently issued a statement acknowledging the rejection.

“We acknowledge the Stewards’ decision to reject our petition requesting a Right of Review,” it read.

“We disagree with the interpretation that an FIA document, which makes a competitor aware of an objective, measurable and provable error in the decision made by the stewards, cannot be an admissible “element” which meets all four criteria set by the ISC, as specified in Article 14.3.

“We would like to thank the FIA and the stewards for having considered this case in a timely manner.

“We will continue to work closely with the FIA to further understand how teams can constructively challenge decisions that lead to an incorrect classification of the race.”

Tags: fialando norrismax verstappenmclaren
Speedcafe Network 100 - logo representing the directory of leading suppliers to the motorsport industry in Australia

List your business today!

Black and green logo reading "EXHAUST SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA" with stylized graphics.

Exhaust Systems Australia

Automotive & Performance

Exhaust Systems Australia is a leading Australian supplier and manufacturer of high-performance and replacement exhaust systems. With operations in Victoria and Queensland, the company serves both professional installers and DIY enthusiasts, offering a comprehensive range...

Exhaust Systems Australia is a leading Australian supplier and manufacturer of high-performance and replacement exhaust systems. With operations in Victoria and Queensland, the company serves...

Discussion about this post

[postcode_search_form]

Latest from Torquecafe

Why Ford turned its work ute into a touring beast

06 December 2025

The most misunderstood car of the year

06 December 2025

Latest Podcasts

PODCAST: Mostert’s Supercars crown + Piastri’s F1 title reality

02 December 2025

PODCAST: McLaren unlucky in Vegas + Adelaide Grand Final preview

25 November 2025

Related Articles

Joanne Ciconte has reflected on her debut year in F1 Academy. Image: XPB Images

Ciconte reflects on ‘surreal’ rookie F1 Academy season

F1
8 hours ago
F1
0

From chaos to champions: Revisiting F1’s modern title showdowns

F1
10 hours ago
F1
0
Platinum Partner

Latest & Trending News

Michael Jordan departs the Charles R Jonas Federal Building in Charlotte, North Carolina, on December Grant Baldwin/Getty Images

Michael Jordan Takes the Stand as Charter Trial Tensions Reach New Peak

NASCAR US
6 December 2025
NASCAR US
0
Chaz Mostert celebrates the 2025 title. Image: Supplied

Supercars set to tweak Finals Series rules for 2026

Supercars
6 December 2025
Supercars
0
BROOKLYN, MICHIGAN - JUNE 07: Michael Annett, driver of the #1 AllState Parts and Service Group Chevrolet, stands in the garage area during practice for the NASCAR Xfinity Series LTi Printing 250 at Michigan International Speedway on June 07, 2019 in Brooklyn, Michigan. (Photo by Matt Sullivan/Getty Images)

Former NASCAR driver Michael Annett, dead at 39

NASCAR US
6 December 2025
NASCAR US
0
Joanne Ciconte has reflected on her debut year in F1 Academy. Image: XPB Images

Ciconte reflects on ‘surreal’ rookie F1 Academy season

F1
6 December 2025
F1
0

WIN: Ryan Wood race-worn and signed gloves

Christmas Giveway
6 December 2025
Christmas Giveway
0

From chaos to champions: Revisiting F1’s modern title showdowns

F1
6 December 2025
F1
0

Advertisement

Pirtek Poll

POLL: Your verdict on the Supercars Finals Series format

Vote View Results Past polls
Pirtek Poll
View past polls
2025 Supercars Championship WINS POLES PTS
1
Chaz Mostert
Mobil 1 Optus Racing
25 4 1 5306
2
Will Brown
Red Bull Ampol Racing
1 2 1 5244
3
Broc Feeney
Red Bull Ampol Racing
88 14 19 5240
4
Kai Allen
Penrite Racing
26 0 0 5233
5
Matthew Payne
Penrite Racing
19 5 1 4461
2025 Formula 1 Championship WINS POLES PTS
1
Lando Norris (GBR)
McLaren
4 7 7 408
2
Max Verstappen (NED)
Red Bull
1 7 7 396
3
Oscar Piastri (AUS)
McLaren
81 7 6 392
4
George Russell (GBR)
Mercedes
63 2 2 309
5
Charles Leclerc (MON)
Ferrari
16 0 1 230
[instagram-feed feed=2]
Support the partners that support Speedcafe
Truck Assist R & J Batteries Pirtek Mobil Super Supercheap Auto Michelin Meguiars coates KTM FORD ACDelco parcelprotect become a partner
AASA PPQ Authentic Collectables sportsnetholidays nuevasolutions bathurst
Green and white "speedcafe." logo on a black background, conveying a racing theme.
Speedcafe.com has been established to provide a daily motorsport news service to the industry and fans in Australia and internationally.
Follow Us

Categories

SUPERCARS

F1

NASCAR

INDYCAR

GT

MOTOGP

PHOTOS

TV

PODS

Platinum Partners

TRUCK ASSIST
R&J BATTERIES
PIRTEK
MOBIL1
SUPERCHEAP AUTO

PARCEL PROTECT

MICHELIN
MEGUIARS

COATES
FORD

ACDELCO

Newsletter

Subscribe to our daily newsletter, the best way to get your news first, fast and free!

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

Your daily racing fix - Newsletter

Subscribe to our daily and breaking newsletter for all the latest news delivered direct to your box

SUBSCRIBE
Follow Us

Categories

SUPERCARS

F1

NASCAR

INDYCAR

GT

MOTOGP

PHOTOS

TV

PODS

Platinum Partners

TRUCK ASSIST
R&J BATTERIES
PIRTEK
MOBIL1
SUPERCHEAP AUTO

PARCEL PROTECT

MICHELIN
MEGUIARS

COATES
FORD

XPEL

ACDELCO

Green and white "speedcafe." logo on a black background, conveying a racing theme.

Copyright © 2025 Speedcafe.com. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Our Team    /  Advertise with us  /  Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Event guides
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Network 100

Copyright © 2025 Speedcafe.com This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Results
  • Event guides
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Network 100

Copyright © 2025 Speedcafe.com This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

[mailpoet_form id=”28″]